Does one-step warming outperform conventional multi-step protocols for vitrified blastocysts?

November 19, 2026

In this single-center validation study, single-step warming improved post-warming blastocyst survival, intactness, and transfer-related measures versus conventional multi-step warming. Ongoing pregnancy rates were comparable, while miscarriage rates were numerically lower with single-step warming across all subgroups.¹

De Gheselle and colleagues ran a three-phase validation at a single university-based IVF center, comparing single-step warming (Vit Kit-Warm NX) against the clinic’s conventional multi-step protocol (Vit Kit-Warm, used through July 2022).

In the preclinical phase, 246 vitrified blastocysts, either donated after the legal storage period or deemed non-transferable following PGT, were warmed with the single-step protocol and compared with 379 historical multi-step controls. Subgroups included non-biopsied Day 5, biopsied Day 5, and biopsied Day 6 blastocysts. A historical non-biopsied Day 6 control was unavailable because the center had not vitrified non-biopsied embryos on Day 6 during the relevant earlier period.

Survival was defined as ≥50% intact cells, full intactness as 100% intact cells, and transfer suitability as ≥50% intact cells at two hours post-warming. Single-step-warmed blastocysts also underwent 24-hour time-lapse observation and live/dead fluorescent staining.

After a successful preclinical phase, the clinic adopted single-step warming for all cycles in March 2024 and ran a retrospective comparison against prior multi-step cycles, tracking total survival (≥50% intact), full survival (100% intact), transfer rate, and pregnancy outcomes (beta-hCG positive, clinical pregnancy, ongoing pregnancy at 10–12 weeks, and miscarriage rate).

In the preclinical phase, single-step warming outperformed multi-step across every category: 99% survival versus 97%, 85% fully intact immediately post-warm versus 76%, and 97% of blastocysts suitable for transfer versus 91%.

The clinical phase showed the same pattern. Survival and full intactness rates were significantly higher with single-step warming across most subgroups (for example, non-PGT Day 5 survival came in at 98.5% versus 96.1%, and full intactness reached as high as 93.4% versus 77.9% in PGT Day 5 blastocysts). Transfer rates followed suit, significantly higher in three of four subgroups. Ongoing pregnancy rates didn’t differ significantly between protocols in any subgroup, and while a couple of early pregnancy measures favored multi-step warming, miscarriage rates trended lower with single-step warming across all subgroups.

Across both phases, single-step warming improved post-warming blastocyst intactness and transfer-related measures, while ongoing pregnancy rates were comparable to the conventional protocol.

The authors describe single-step warming as a way to reduce procedural complexity and handling time without compromising embryo viability or ongoing pregnancy outcomes for labs looking to streamline cryopreservation workflow.

Sources:

  1. De Gheselle S, De Vuyst L, Lierman S, De Croo I, Vanden Meerschaut F, Stoop D, Tilleman K. Single-step warming for blastocysts: a clinically validated alternative to conventional multi-step protocols. Hum Reprod. 2026;00(00):1–10. doi:10.1093/humrep/deag021